Sunday, September 25, 2011

Will the Public Cloud Model of Computing Dominate in 2020?

I am always interested at how we often fail to see ‘shades of grey’ and instead tend to view choices as being binary.

I have spent the past several years arguing that we are going to source the bulk of our IT resources from remote datacenters that are managed by third parties and that browsers will be the interfaces that we use for these activities. I still believe this to be the case except that increasingly, we will access these resources by using apps on our lighter and more portable devices.

Nevertheless, many still view cloud computing as a binary decision. Either adopt cloud computing across the board and expose yourself to all the risks associated with it, or you do not adopt it and continue to invest in on-premise resources. Clearly, this is not and never will be the case.

Cloud computing, in many ways, is making IT more complex. It is adding yet another dimension to heterogeneous IT environments. Corporate IT environments typically consist of a mix of mainframe technology from the 1960s and 1970s, client/server technology and cloud computing technology. This will continue. Cloud computing technology will increasingly be deployed in the form of private clouds and public clouds. It will soon be the dominant IT environment as client/server technology gets displaced.

However, client/server and mainframe technology will not disappear. It will instead account for a smaller proportion of IT infrastructures. In the meantime, large organizations will focus on integrating cloud computing with their existing infrastructures and this will be a major focus over the next few years. Already, systems integrators are massively benefiting from the huge opportunity that this additional complexity brings to them.

There will be a steady move to adopting IT resources, where appropriate from the public cloud. This is where the real disruption will occur. Why invest in on-site technology whether it is so called private cloud technology or other legacy technology, when you can access the necessary resources over the public Internet? In other words, why not source as much as possible from the cloud?

Some argue that there is a move back to processing on local devices. It is true that many apps carry out processing on local devices, but the bulk of processing and IT activity will occur remotely. Apps will offer some customization and, in my view, are a way of making the cloud work more effectively. They offer more personalized ‘windows to the cloud’ than is the case with traditional browsers. Indeed, browsers will be used much less often as a way of accessing the cloud.

In summary, more and more resources will be sourced from the public cloud. This is the real impact of cloud computing. Public cloud resources will need to be integrated with on-site investments which are made up of legacy mainframe and client/server systems as well as more recent datacenter or private cloud investments. By 2020, on-site IT activity will account for a very small proportion of an organization’s overall IT activity. In other words, the public cloud will be the dominant model of computing very soon.

Sunday, August 7, 2011

Managing Complexity in the Cloud

Although cloud computing offers enormous benefits to today’s organizations, it also adds to the overall complexity of IT environments.

If the bulk of IT resources and workloads, including IT management and monitoring, were sourced remotely from the cloud, IT environments would, in many ways, be simplified and would focus to a greater extent on the provision of business services and business value to organizations.

However, most IT resources continue to remain on-premise and need to be integrated with and to co-ordinate with resources and services that are sourced from the cloud. This adds to the overall complexity of most enterprise IT environments. Indeed, many of today’s organizations are working with a mix of proprietary mainframe technology, client/server technology, other on-premise resources such as private clouds and public clouds (in which resources reside off-site).

For this reason, there is a much greater need for tools that can manage and monitor integrated cloud and on-premise IT environments. Consequently, many enterprise customers are placing greater emphasis on cloud management software strategies. Organizations are searching for an end to end, top down view of complex business processes and workloads, in order to increase productivity and engender greater business agility. Managing these environments goes way beyond provisioning and VM sprawl reduction. Security management, performance management, utlilization, availability, compliance, and productivity all need to be addressed by management tools.

So, managing and monitoring complex heterogeneous IT environments, in which an increasingly large proportion of IT resources are being delivered from the cloud is critical. Most management and monitoring tools remain on-premise and integrated with legacy infrastructure. Addressing changing needs which are often driven by migration to cloud computing is a major challenge for legacy on-premise implementations of IT management and monitoring software. Therefore, for buyers of IT management software, it increasingly makes logical sense to seek flexible and scalable SaaS versions of IT management software or IT management as a service.

In a recent discussion between myself and some Nimsoft executives, we discussed the SaaS market for IT management and monitoring. Nimsoft combines IT monitoring and service management to provide ITIL based IT Management as a service. It is joined by many small companies such as Spiceworks and Zenoss which have emerged to offer IT management as a service, as well as the larger traditional IT management firms. IT management as a service, offered by companies such as Nimsoft, is much easier to implement and use than traditional on premise IT management and monitoring products. The largest enterprises with the most complex IT environments will continue to express concern about the security, stability and strategic fit of cloud solutions. Nevertheless, IT management as a service offers enormous benefits to small and medium sized businesses and objections from the largest companies can be expected to be steadily overcome.

The ability of IT management as a service products to be integrated with on-premise resources as well as public cloud services, is critical. Organizations now need a console view of their complete IT environments as well as the benefits of cloud computing such as rapid provisioning, agility and scalability. The IT management as a service market, together with other cloud middleware markets, which focus on other forms of cloud computing enablement, will become prominent over the next year. Furthermore, IT management as a service will soon be commonly found in the largest organizations.

Sunday, July 17, 2011

China in Pole Position for Cloud Computing Opportunities

Although cloud computing has been slow to take off in much of APAC, this is starting to change as more geographies become ‘cloud ready’. Most interest in cloud computing adoption in APAC, is, of course, directed at the region’s largest economy, China.

This can be explained by the strongly held view that China will offer the greatest cloud computing opportunities in the world within the next five years. China does not have the legacy infrastructure of the more mature economies and is investing huge amounts into new infrastructure that will enable the provision of cloud computing services and make the adoption of these services very attractive.

In mature economies, large organizations have typically invested millions of dollars in on-premise infrastructure. In order to see a return on their investments, these organizations are often reluctant to move into a world where most infrastructure, applications and content reside off-site. Strong vested interests also impede the adoption of cloud computing. A shift to using cloud services at the expense of on premise infrastructure, challenges the role of IT departments. Hence, many within IT departments are reluctant to propose cloud computing options. Similarly, suppliers of hardware and software to large organizations may view cloud computing as a threat to strong revenue streams from their legacy businesses. These organizations are unlikely to propose options to their clients that reduce the size of a deal.

Organizations in China and in some other geographies in the APAC region such as India, Thailand, Indonesia and Vietnam don’t face these challenges. The biggest challenge that they face is infrastructure and the impact of this infrastructure (or lack of it) on the performance and availability of cloud computing. However, this is changing rapidly, particularly within China.

In China, cities such as Shanghai, Shenzhen, Guangzhou and Ordos now have infrastructure that lends itself to the extremely rapid takeup of cloud computing services. Massive data centers are being built such as the data center in Langfang, Hebei province (being built by IBM and Range Technology) to meet demand for cloud services, in particular IaaS.

China’s strong position is compounded by the readiness of large telecommunications vendors such as China Telecom and China Mobile to offer cloud computing services, and the growth in local Chinese suppliers of cloud computing services. Indeed, Microsoft is now working with China Mobile to develop and deliver cloud services while SAP is doing the same with China Telecom. Both global software companies, clearly recognize the importance of establishing themselves in the Chinese cloud computing market. Examples of Chinese suppliers of cloud services are Kingdee and Ufida. Both companies have a heritage in the provision of on –premise software. Both are now making strategic moves to ensure that they are major suppliers of software as a service in China.

In summary, it has become clear only in the last few months that parts of China now have the infrastructure to enable the provision of cloud computing services; the suppliers positioned to deliver these services; and demand for these services. They do not have the same brake on cloud computing adoption, namely legacy business and investments, which exists in mature economies. Key regions within China are now poised to offer some of the most significant cloud computing opportunities in the world.

Sunday, May 15, 2011

Social Media and Innovation in the Financial Services Sector

I recently attended a conference on IT in financial services in Macau and had the opportunity to meet with several CIOs from prominent financial services organizations in the Asia Pacific region.

During the event, much discussion was around innovation. Financial services organizations are exploring ways in which technology can engender innovation, such as the manner in which they engage with their customers and the types of products and services that they offer.

Financial services firms have a very strong history of using technology to engage with customers in new and innovative ways. For example, Internet banking was quick to emerge once Web usage became widespread. Similarly, smart phone bank apps appeared very rapidly and allow us to interact with banks using our smart phones.

Social media also offers opportunities to innovate in the way financial services firms interface with their customers and other stakeholders. However, most financial services organizations in Asia Pacific are more pre-occupied with blocking employee access to social media than engendering innovative use of social media. The reason for this is usually given as a need to adhere to internal policies. But what is driving such policies? In my discussions with CIOs, the need for security and data leakage prevention was mixed up with concerns around productivity. To me, these are two totally different beasts and need to be addressed in totally different ways.

Data leakage and other aspects of security must be addressed comprehensively by financial services organizations. Is it necessary to block or to restrict access to social media to achieve these goals? Products such as Zscaler allow organizations to offer access to social media while preventing any uploads or downloads. It enables organizations to separate security and productivity concerns that are associated with social media. Such products address security risks while permitting access to social media. I know of at least one major financial services organization in Asia that uses Zscaler for precisely this reason. The CIO believes that allowing staff to use social media can enable them to work more efficiently and engender innovation. He stated that even though he doesn’t use social media extensively for his work, he recognizes that he cannot force others to approach their work in the same way, especially younger workers. In this particular institution, there is no longer a concern around falling productivity because of social media usage. It acknowledges that attempting to restrict access to social media is a losing battle and will eventually backfire as social media tools become increasingly widespread within businesses.

Concerns around falling productivity existed around the use of spreadsheets in the 1980s and around the Web in the 1990s. These concerns have proved to be unfounded as employees found new ways in which these tools could support them in doing their jobs. The same is the case with social media. Ultimately, employees must be measured on their performance. No link has been demonstrated between improved employee performance and restrictions on social media. It is doubtful that the two are even related. Financial services institutions must focus on real issues that impact them when social media is used. They need to concern themselves with engendering innovation and allowing individual employees to work in the ways that make them productive, while addressing the security issues around these activities. Social media will be a key tool for financial services as they innovate, enhance customer experience, and make themselves more competitive. Indeed, blocking and restricting access to social media, based on unproven productivity concerns may well make financial services firms less competitive, less efficient and less productive.

Thursday, April 21, 2011

Offshore Outsourcing - The Unspeakable Taboo

I recently participated in a contact centre industry event in Sydney. Predictably, many of the vendors that sponsored and presented at the event were promoting offshore contact centre services.

The sales messages, as always were very compelling. Offshore contact centre destinations such as the Philippines offer many benefits above and beyond lowering costs. The availability of skilled staff who are willing to work as contact centre agents is much greater than in mature economies.

However, what was most interesting to me was the unwillingness of delegates to openly talk about the benefits of sourcing contact centre services from offshore locations. Talking positively about offshore outsourcing has now become taboo. Companies that purchase these services prefer not to discuss them at all. Financial services organisations, in particular, seem terrified of negative stories appearing in the press about them ‘sending local jobs overseas’ and creating unemployment in their home markets. Worse still, they fear being forced to justify their business decisions to politicians that take a steadily growing interest in their operational activities.

Indeed, offshore outsourcing has become a major political issue. The most commonly articulated views on this matter are negative. Few politicians will argue publicly in favour of sourcing services from offshore destinations. Only the business press writes about any of the benefits of offshoring.

To me, the success of the offshore outsourcing market is one of the few obvious benefits that globalisation delivers to ordinary people. It creates jobs and business in parts of the world that have been starved of investment and opportunities. It also enables poorer countries to sell services to rich countries. Today, Australia sells a lot more to India than India does to Australia. So, it doesn’t seem right that people should complain about the balance of trade becoming more even as Australian companies buy more services from India. We cannot continue to live in a world where a few countries hoard most of the wealth and create international trading environments that reinforce global inequalities.

Indeed, large businesses in Western countries prefer not to discuss the massive benefits that offshoring is offering to communities in poorer countries. They seem to be unwilling to stand their ground on this issue. In the case of offshoring, it is one of the few areas in which financial services organisations can claim to be on the moral high ground.

An interesting paradox has emerged in Western countries. It is often argued that those that work in the banking sector must continue to receive very large bonus payments or their jobs will go offshore. On the other hand, it is also argued that we must be in a position to lower the costs associated with employing ordinary workers or risk their jobs going offshore. Many of those in the financial services sector are happy to publicly justify sky high bonuses that clearly demonstrate market failure to any student of economics. On the other hand, they are much less likely to publicly justify an activity in which the market is working to the benefit of ordinary people, namely the provision of services from poorer countries that benefit hugely from this trade.

Sunday, March 13, 2011

Hail the Consumer Cloud

Most cloud-computing related discussion has focused on the use of cloud computing by businesses and government.

However,among consumers, we are witnessing a shift to full cloud computing by stealth. Already, consumers use well known consumer cloud offerings, such as Google’s offerings, Facebook and other collaboration and sharing applications. Video and music streaming are becoming more common. For example, Spotify offers access to an enormous catalogue of music which can be streamed. There are no files to download. Customers pay a subscription fee per month.

Will the notion of files residing locally on devices owned by consumers soon seem quaint and old-fashioned? For music and video, will files become rare as streaming takes over? In effect, consumer choice is driving a shift away from files. Firms like Spotify will undermine the iTunes model of purchasing content as consumers cease to own discrete pieces of content but instead gain access to vast warehouses of content.

True, consumers continue to use personal productivity software products such as Microsoft Office which reside locally. But, for how much longer? Cloud-based alternatives are available including products from Microsoft, and these are witnessing very rapid uptake.

Offerings such as iCloud that provide virtual desktops can be expected to gradually displace traditional PC software. Dropbox offers storage as a service and is widely used by consumers. Other consumer offerings that are experiencing rapid uptake are the chargeable Amazon S3 and the Rackspace Cloud.

The consumer IT market has in recent years seen the emergence of new technology giants such as Facebook and Google. Microsoft has continued to address consumer needs and is shifting to cloud computing rapidly. These firms understand consumers and the impact of their behaviours and choices on business and government computing. It is the more traditional IT suppliers which have more distant consumer relationships that stand to lose as consumers drive yet more change in the IT business.

Thursday, February 10, 2011

Cloud Computing Specialisation and the Emergence of Local Champions

I recently attended an announcement of the launch of an Australia-based IaaS firm, Ninefold. The firm addresses many of the challenges created by cloud computing. Its local IaaS offerings represent a key part of the evolution of cloud computing and the emergence of a utility based form of computing.

Most of us have heard about the benefits of cloud computing such as rapid provisioning, usage based pricing, multitenancy (leading to economies of scale), greater scalability, instant updates, and a reduced need to hire scarce skills.

We are also familiar with the challenges associated with cloud computing, such as quality of service issues, provision of support and data sovereignty. Overcoming these challenges is critical, if cloud computing is to evolve further.

At present, data is subject to the regulations of the country in which it sits. As yet, there are no international regulations that protect data from misuse. Such regulations are necessary to overcome concerns about data sovereignty. The WikiLeaks saga has damaged confidence in overseas cloud providers and Amazon has done a lot to cause this, by bowing down to pressure from politicians. Plenty of people may not like the actions of WikiLeaks but its actions have not been proved to be illegal. This precedent suggests that if US politicians do not like what a business is doing or are corrupt (this is possible), they can interfere with cloud-based businesses. Therefore, it is reasonable to assume that politicians in other jurisdictions, like their US counterparts, may choose to interfere with a business, foreign or domestic, because they do not like its activities. This is a very compelling argument for keeping data close to the organisation.

Cloud services that are provided from international locations are often unable to offer the latency and speed that is required for certain activities. Cloud services that are provided in-country or even in the same city can offer higher performance levels. This is another argument for keeping data nearby.

Cloud services such as those offered from US-based datacentres, offer great value for money. But, this service typically does not offer any local support. Although cloud computing reduces the need for support dramatically, some local support will be necessary for some organisations. A lack of available support will also act as a hindrance to the adoption of some Amazon-style cloud computing services.

Companies are emerging that seek to address key challenges associated with cloud computing and to provide offerings that are more specifically targeted. Ninefold offers IaaS that is comparable with Amazon’s offerings, except that it addresses many of the challenges associated with using Amazon. Issues with data sovereignty are immediately overcome as its datacentres are located in Australia and its offerings are targeted at Australia-based customers. Issues with quality of service, in particular latency and speed, are addressed by the relative proximity of Ninefold’s datacentres to customer premises. Finally, support issues are addressed by the provision of local support.

Ninefold can be seen as part of the evolution of cloud computing as we move to a utility model of computing. Instead of offering standard services across the globe, it has specialised in serving one geography, Australia. Continued specialisation can be expected as customers demand cloud services that meet increasingly specific requirements. What form will this specialisation take at a local level?